An attempt to sort every game I've ever played into a single ordered list.
630 Games have been fully considered for ranking so far.

  1. Killer7
  2. Kentucky Route Zero – Act III
  3. Dwarf Fortress
  4. River City Ransom/Street Gangs
  5. Super Mario Bros. 3
  6. Nier: Automata
  7. Caves of Qud
  8. Super Mario World
  9. Nethack
  10. Omori
  11. Norco
  12. Deus Ex
  13. Unavowed
  14. Heaven's Vault
  15. Kentucky Route Zero – Un Pueblo De Nada
  16. Disco Elysium
  17. Doom
  18. Noita
  19. Maniac Mansion
  20. Final Fantasy VII
  21. Daytona USA
  22. Bayonetta 2
  23. Forza Motorsport 3
  24. Gran Turismo 4
  25. Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA)
  26. Metal Gear Solid
  27. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
  28. To The Moon
  29. Frog Fractions – Hop’s Iconic Cap DLC
  30. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
  31. Alley Cat
  32. Paratopic
  33. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
  34. Bayonetta
  35. Paradise Killer
  36. Rez
  37. Chicory: A Colorful Tale
  38. The Longest Journey
  39. Portal
  40. Wreckfest
  41. Chrono Trigger
  42. Half-Life 2
  43. Elasto Mania
  44. Tetris 99
  45. Soko-Ban
  46. International Superstar Soccer 64
  47. The Forgotten City
  48. Rogue
  49. Firewatch
  50. Missile Command
  51. Transport Tycoon
  52. Resident Evil 4
  53. 1001 Spikes
  54. Vampire Survivors
  55. DoomRL
  56. Super Mario Bros.
  57. Kentucky Route Zero – The Entertainment
  58. If On A Winter's Night, Four Travelers
  59. Become a Great Artist in Just 10 Seconds
  60. Kentucky Route Zero – Act II
  61. Kentucky Route Zero – Act I
  62. 80 Days
  63. Cave Story
  64. Quake II
  65. Dujanah
  66. Exapunks
  67. Quake
  68. Portal 2
  69. Outrun
  70. Tetris (Game Boy)
  71. Lisa: The Painful RPG
  72. GoldenEye 007
  73. Bionic Commando
  74. La Mulana
  75. Snatcher
  76. Super Meat Boy
  77. Jara-Tava: The Isle of Fire
  78. Tekken 3
  79. The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
  80. Nelson Tethers: Puzzle Agent
  81. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
  82. Opus Magnum
  83. Half-Life
  84. Hades
  85. Glittermitten Grove
  86. Doom II
  87. Nuclear Throne
  88. Stardew Valley
  89. Quake III: Arena
  90. Fez
  91. Nightmare Reaper
  92. Microsoft Flight Simulator X
  93. VVVVVV
  94. Hexcells Infinite
  95. Exile
  96. Unexplored
  97. Live A Live
  98. Dark Souls
  99. Mario Kart DS
  100. The Hex
  101. Trackmania United
  102. FTL: Faster Than Light
  103. Xenoblade Chronicles X
  104. Cellar
  105. Enclosure
  106. Blade Runner
  107. Sonic Dreams Collection
  108. Frog Fractions
  109. Jumpman (Run Hello)
  110. Super Mario Kart
  111. Sumatra: Fate of Yandi
  112. Hidden In Plain Sight
  113. The Stanley Parable
  114. Bubsy 3D: Bubsy Visits the James Turrell Retrospective
  115. Audiosurf
  116. Fantasy of Expedition
  117. The Curse of Monkey Island
  118. Mega Man 3
  119. Super Mario Galaxy 2
  120. Mega Man 2
  121. Gone Home
  122. Metroid Prime
  123. Streets of Rogue
  124. American Truck Simulator
  125. FAITH
  126. Alan Wake
  127. Mega Man 9
  128. Mass Effect
  129. Solitaire
  130. Psychonauts
  131. Beyond Good and Evil
  132. Indy 500
  133. Monolith: After the End/Star of Providence
  134. Football Game
  135. Street Fighter II
  136. Diaries of a Spaceport Janitor
  137. Pleurghburg: Dark Ages
  138. Minecraft
  139. Tempest 2000
  140. Proteus
  141. La Mulana 2
  142. Braid
  143. Grand Theft Auto
  144. Mega Man X
  145. Indycar Racing II
  146. Remnants
  147. Sagebrush
  148. Spelunky (HD)
  149. Neo Turf Masters
  150. A Monster's Expedition Through Puzzling Exhibitions
  151. The Tea Room
  152. Double Dragon II: The Revenge
  153. Dino Run DX
  154. Super Smash Bros.: Melee
  155. Postal2
  156. Minesweeper
  157. Darwinia
  158. Final Fight
  159. Canabalt
  160. Rogue Shooter: The FPS Roguelike
  161. Digger
  162. Terranigma
  163. Cruelty Squad
  164. SpaceTeam
  165. Desert Golfing
  166. Donkey Kong
  167. The Swapper
  168. The Binding of Isaac
  169. Blades of Steel
  170. Sid Meier's Railroad Tycoon
  171. Boulder Dash
  172. NBA Hangtime
  173. Technobabylon
  174. Nidhogg
  175. NBA Jam
  176. Don't Escape: 4 Days to Survive
  177. Devil Daggers
  178. N
  179. Final Fantasy V
  180. Into The Breach
  181. The Need For Speed
  182. Wizardry 6: Bane of the Cosmic Forge
  183. Lyle In Cube Sector
  184. ADOM
  185. Micro Machines 2
  186. Final Fantasy IV (II)
  187. Iron Lung
  188. Gemini Rue
  189. Strangeland
  190. Microprose Grand Prix II
  191. Primordia
  192. Night in the Woods
  193. Starcraft
  194. Stunts
  195. Terraria
  196. Beat Hazard
  197. Pac-Man: Championship DX
  198. Rollcage
  199. Antichamber
  200. Brutal Orchestra
  201. Factorio
  202. Barkley Shut and Jam: Gaiden - Chapter 1 - The Hoopz Barkley Saga
  203. Wave Race 64
  204. Legend of Grimrock
  205. The Legend of the Bear-Truck Trucker
  206. Pokemon Snap
  207. Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes
  208. Carmageddon
  209. else Heart.Break()
  210. Hyper V-Ball
  211. 868-Hack
  212. My Summer Car
  213. The Talos Principle
  214. SimCity 4
  215. Dead Island
  216. Defcon
  217. Lisa: The Joyful
  218. SimCity
  219. Knytt
  220. Liberal Crime Squad
  221. Kentucky Route Zero – Act IV
  222. Bik
  223. Wilmot’s Warehouse
  224. Mortal Kombat (9)
  225. Tales of Symphonia
  226. Mastaba Snoopy
  227. Madworld
  228. Another World
  229. The Simpsons (Arcade)
  230. Citizen Abel: Gravity Bone
  231. The Sims
  232. Dark Souls II
  233. Wolfenstein 3D
  234. 1080° Snowboarding
  235. Intergalactic Fishing
  236. Kentucky Route Zero – Act V
  237. Duskers
  238. No Man’s Sky
  239. The Last of Us
  240. Within A Deep Forest
  241. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
  242. Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars
  243. Delver
  244. FIFA 2000
  245. Seiklus
  246. Motocross Madness
  247. Zombies Ate My Neighbors
  248. Wonder Boy in Monster World
  249. New Star Soccer 3
  250. Myst
  251. World Class Leaderboard
  252. Crazy Taxi
  253. Puzzle Agent 2
  254. Dead Rising
  255. NBA Live 95
  256. Super Mario 3D World
  257. Thrustburst
  258. Kentucky Route Zero – Here And There Along The Echo
  259. Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals
  260. Theme Park
  261. Da New Guys: Day of the Jackass
  262. N+
  263. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (Arcade)
  264. Golden Axe
  265. Guitar Hero
  266. Age of Empires
  267. Faith: Chapter II
  268. Hexcells Plus
  269. Enduro Racer (Master System)
  270. Sid Meier's Civilization V
  271. QWOP
  272. Raiden
  273. Wayne Gretzky's 3D Hockey
  274. Super Baseball 2020
  275. Sonic The Hedgehog
  276. Super Sidekicks
  277. SkiFree
  278. Rex: Another Island
  279. #IDARB
  280. Hexcells
  281. Kentucky Route Zero – Death of The Hired Man
  282. Chip’s Challenge
  283. San Francisco Rush: Extreme Racing
  284. Oikospiel Book I
  285. Garry’s Mod
  286. Deus Ex: Human Revolution
  287. Plok!
  288. Resident Evil 5
  289. Puzzle Bots
  290. The Blackwell Deception
  291. World of Horror
  292. Shadow Complex
  293. 5 Days a Stranger
  294. Thirty Flights of Loving
  295. Peggle
  296. Kentucky Route Zero – Limits and Demonstrations
  297. The Longing
  298. Pilotwings 64
  299. Mario Paint
  300. Beneath A Steel Sky
  301. Sine Mora
  302. Mystery of Time and Space
  303. Spec Ops:The Line
  304. Kevin Keegan's Player Manager
  305. Virtua Cop 2
  306. Lotus Esprit Turbo Challenge
  307. F-Zero
  308. Re-Volt
  309. Wildermyth
  310. Hotline Miami
  311. Super Amazing Wagon Adventure
  312. PySol Fan Club Edition
  313. Dishonored
  314. Mine Storm
  315. Powerslide
  316. Heretic
  317. Moto Racer
  318. Dreamfall: The Longest Journey
  319. Die Hard Trilogy
  320. Alex Kidd in Miracle World
  321. Magic Sword
  322. An Airport for Aliens Currently Run by Dogs
  323. Ynglet
  324. Hyper Demon
  325. L.A. Noire
  326. Dino Dini's Soccer
  327. Golf It
  328. Gish
  329. Station 37
  330. Ice Hockey
  331. Mean 18
  332. Yie Ar Kung Fu
  333. Killer Instinct Gold
  334. Toribash
  335. Entity (2021 Bitsy game)
  336. Big Red Racing
  337. Prince of Persia
  338. Abzû
  339. Lemmings
  340. PUBG: Battlegrounds
  341. Enigma
  342. Tecmo Super Bowl
  343. One Way Heroics
  344. F-19 Stealth Fighter
  345. A Date in the Park
  346. Red Baron
  347. Unreal
  348. The Blackwell Convergence
  349. Super Smash Bros. for Wii U
  350. Ninja Gaiden
  351. The Telwynium: Book One
  352. Resonance
  353. Grow RPG
  354. Rock n' Roll Racing
  355. The Blackwell Epiphany
  356. Aussie Rules Footy
  357. Life of D. Duck II
  358. The Consortium
  359. Blast Corps
  360. Loop Hero
  361. Mario Kart 64
  362. Wizorb
  363. Need For Speed II
  364. Genital Jousting
  365. MindMaze (Encarta 1994)
  366. Unforeseen Incidents
  367. Wizball
  368. Brain Lord
  369. Star Fox/Wing
  370. Worms Armageddon
  371. Her Story
  372. Leisure Suit Larry in the Land of the Lounge Lizards
  373. Soldier Of Fortune
  374. E.Y.E Divine Cybermancy
  375. Manic Miner
  376. Silkworm
  377. Roberta Williams' King's Quest I: Quest for the Crown
  378. Shogo: Mobile Armor Division
  379. Bomberman 64
  380. Omnibus
  381. Pizza Tycoon
  382. Eternam
  383. Shadowhand: RPG Card Game
  384. Liero
  385. Event[0]
  386. Stacking
  387. Excite Truck
  388. Super Paper Mario
  389. One Must Fall 2097
  390. Brainbug
  391. Tom Clancy’s Rainbow Six
  392. The Touryst
  393. Hugo II: Whodunit?
  394. Universe Sandbox (2008)
  395. Shadowgrounds
  396. Dirt Trax FX
  397. Mortal Kombat Trilogy
  398. Snake Rattle N Roll
  399. Dota 2
  400. Jet Set Willy
  401. Diddy Kong Racing
  402. Divekick
  403. Mu Cartographer
  404. Among Us
  405. Duke Nukem 3D
  406. Side Pocket
  407. Automobili Lamborghini
  408. Borderlands 2
  409. Konami Hyper Soccer
  410. Angband
  411. Deus Ex: Invisible War
  412. 688 Attack Sub
  413. N++
  414. Don't Starve
  415. Shardlight
  416. Blackwell Unbound
  417. Where in the World Is Carmen Sandiego?
  418. 7 Days A Skeptic
  419. Threes
  420. Gnosia
  421. Shower With Your Dad Simulator 2015: Do You Still Shower With Your Dad
  422. Lisa: The First
  423. SiN Episodes: Emergence
  424. Abducted: 10 Minutes
  425. Rag Doll Kung Fu
  426. Goldfields
  427. Commander Keen: Keen Dreams
  428. Heavy Rain
  429. Home
  430. Lemmings 2: The Tribes
  431. Realistic Summer Sports Simulator
  432. Dreamfall Chapters
  433. Retro City Rampage: DX
  434. FRACT OSC
  435. Populous
  436. Dante's Inferno
  437. Battle Chess II: Chinese Chess
  438. New Super Mario Bros. Wii
  439. Battle Chess
  440. The Incredible Machine
  441. Ehrgeiz:God Bless The Ring
  442. Double Dragon
  443. The Charnel House Trilogy
  444. Awesomenauts
  445. Tecmo World Cup Soccer
  446. Donkey Kong Country
  447. Syberia
  448. New Ice York
  449. Fall Guys: Ultimate Knockout
  450. Space Quest II: Chapter II - Vohaul's Revenge
  451. Transformice
  452. Hover!
  453. Mace: The Dark Age
  454. Qooty
  455. The Curse of Rabenstein
  456. California Games
  457. Track & Field II
  458. Fighter’s Destiny
  459. Eliminator Boat Duel
  460. Black & White
  461. A Golden Wake
  462. International Cricket
  463. The Flintstones: The Rescue of Dino & Hoppy
  464. Kobe Bryant in NBA Courtside
  465. Super Soccer
  466. Animal Crossing: New Horizons
  467. Crime Reaper
  468. Donkey Kong Jr
  469. MRC: Multi Racing Championship
  470. Wetrix
  471. Hearts of Iron 3
  472. Shockwave
  473. Space Horb
  474. Granny's Garden
  475. How we Know We’re Alive
  476. Alien Hominid
  477. The Blackwell Legacy
  478. Driver
  479. Robotrek
  480. Detroit: Become Human
  481. The Adventures of Willy Beamish
  482. flOw
  483. Grand Prix Circuit
  484. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (NES)
  485. Arch Rivals
  486. Mouth Sweet
  487. Duck Hunt
  488. Serious Sam 3: BFE
  489. Super Princess Peach
  490. Shadow Warrior (1997)
  491. Astral Chain
  492. Street Racer
  493. Space Commanders
  494. Chesh
  495. 90 Minutes: European Prime Goal
  496. On the Rain-Slick Precipice of Darkness: Episode One
  497. Revolution ‘76
  498. Venice Beach Volleyball
  499. Nigel Mansell's World Championship Racing
  500. Beyond: Two Souls
  501. Xena: Warrior Princess - The Talisman of Fate
  502. The Ford Simulator
  503. Super International Cricket
  504. Dear Esther
  505. NUTS
  506. Mortal Kombat 4
  507. Yoshi’s Story
  508. Parkitect
  509. Hugo III: The Jungle of Doom
  510. Snake’s Revenge
  511. Broforce
  512. The Swords of Ditto: Mormo's Curse
  513. Niosa
  514. Winter Gold
  515. Double Dribble
  516. World League Basketball (SNES)
  517. Cruis'n USA
  518. The Simpsons: Bart vs The Space Mutants
  519. Scribblenauts Unlimited
  520. F-15 Strike Eagle II
  521. The Shivah
  522. Back to the Future: The Game
  523. Signal (Oddly Shaped Pixel)
  524. Brunswick World Tournament of Champions
  525. Microprose Soccer
  526. Clandestinity of Elsie
  527. Lunchtime of the Damned
  528. The Addams Family: Pugsley's Scavenger Hunt
  529. Blocks That Matter
  530. Michigan: Report from Hell
  531. Dudes With Attitude
  532. Back 4 Blood
  533. Loco-Motion
  534. Sluggish Morss Pattern Circus
  535. Expendabros
  536. Strafe
  537. Lost in the Static
  538. Twelve Minutes
  539. PES 2008: Pro Evolution Soccer
  540. Nancy Drew: Trail of the Twister
  541. Chess 2: The Sequel
  542. Stunt Race FX
  543. Jurassic Park (NES)
  544. Cosmo’s Cosmic Adventure
  545. Tell Me Why
  546. Towns
  547. Bokosuka Wars
  548. Don’t Shit Your Pants
  549. Metroid: Other M
  550. Death Race
  551. Amagon
  552. 3-Demon
  553. YIIK
  554. Metroid Prime: Hunters
  555. Fahrenheit
  556. World Games
  557. Moonbase Alpha
  558. Robocop 2
  559. hattrick.org
  560. Defender of the Crown
  561. Future Classics Collection
  562. Rymdkapsel
  563. Trüberbrook
  564. Menace Beach
  565. Daikatana
  566. The Marriage
  567. Planetary Annihilation
  568. MetaVaxx
  569. PC Pool
  570. Bubsy in: Claws Encounters of the Furred Kind
  571. Hugo's House of Horrors
  572. Final Fantasy Mystic Quest
  573. Kosmonavtes: Escape Reality
  574. Somari
  575. Barkley: Shut Up and Jam
  576. The Simpsons: Bart vs The World
  577. Paganitzu
  578. Ultimate ADOM - Caverns of Chaos
  579. Clayfighter 63 1/3
  580. Columns
  581. Bushido
  582. Rad Racket
  583. Double Dragon 3: The Rosetta Stone
  584. James Clavell's Shogun
  585. Actua Soccer 2
  586. Cruis'n World
  587. The Castle Doctrine
  588. ICC Cricket World Cup England 99
  589. Wii Play
  590. Deathbots
  591. Mixed-Up Mother Goose
  592. Tintin on the Moon
  593. Days of Thunder (Non-Cancelled)
  594. Oil’s Well (1990)
  595. Tiles Of Fate
  596. Armchair Quarterback
  597. Capture The Flag
  598. Air Boarder 64
  599. Kick Off
  600. AFL 98
  601. Snowflake Tattoo
  602. IBM PC Wheel of Fortune (Phil Katz)
  603. Krazy Kreatures
  604. Monopoly.com (Ron Gibson)
  605. Monopolize (One Player)
  606. Bad Street Brawler
  607. Stakk’M
  608. Pango
  609. Chiller
  610. Mario Is Missing
  611. BlackJack (NES)
  612. F-15 City War
  613. Backgammon (Mark Geer)
  614. Bio F.R.E.A.K.S.
  615. Postal
  616. Solitaire (NES)
  617. The Triathron
  618. Bomb Sweeper
  619. Split or Steal
  620. Diamond Rider
  621. Poko Memorial: 18 Hole Miniature Golf
  622. PC GOLF
  623. Astrotit
  624. Fuck Quest
  625. AFL Finals Fever
  626. PUZZLE (NES)
  627. Learning With Leeper
  628. Hall of Tortured Souls
  629. Godus
  630. Postal III

Congratulations to Killer7!
The greatest game of all time!

GOD BLESS THE RANK!

An UNCREATIVE OUTPUT production.